Short answer
Ask who will actually visit, how they handle your pet on leash and at the door, what happens if a visit runs late or the sitter is sick, how updates work, and what they do in an emergency, including when they call your vet. Ask about medication and keys, and notice what the sitter asks you. For a nervous pet, keep the meeting calm and let your pet approach on its own.
What a meet-and-greet is for
Most professional sitters meet you at home before the first booking. Pet Sitters International (PSI), a professional association for pet sitters, describes this meeting as a chance for the sitter to meet you, interact with your pet and go over services and business policies. PSI notes that some companies offer it at no charge and others charge a fee.
At Danny's Pet Care, every new client books a meet-and-greet through our application form before we schedule visits, and our dog-sitting page calls it a free consultation. Two reviews on our testimonials page describe Danny coming to the first meeting along with the sitter who would do the visits.
Bring your questions, but also watch. How the sitter greets your pet, and how your pet responds, can tell you as much as any answer. If you are still comparing companies, start with our guide on how to choose a pet sitter or dog walker, which covers licenses, insurance and reviews. Danny's Pet Care says its sitters are insured and background-checked; the meet-and-greet is a good time to ask us, or anyone, for proof.
Questions about who comes and how they handle your pet
Ask these in your own words. The note after each question is what you are listening for.
- Who will actually visit? Ask whether the person you are meeting is your regular sitter or walker, and who fills in. Your pet may settle faster with a familiar face, and you want to know who holds your key.
- How do you handle the door? Ask how they come in and leave without letting your dog or cat slip out. In a rowhouse whose front door opens onto the sidewalk, one slip can put a pet on a busy street.
- Leash, harness or collar? Show them the gear your dog uses and ask how they check the fit. Ask what they do if your dog pulls, lunges or freezes on the walk.
- What about other dogs? Ask how they pass other dogs on the sidewalk, and whether your dog will walk alone or with others. Danny's Pet Care offers group walks, with dogs paired by temperament and energy level, and private walks for dogs that don't do well walking with other dogs.
- What does a visit include? Feeding, water, litter, play, potty breaks, and how long they stay. Our post on what a professional pet sitter does during a visit walks through a typical visit.
Questions about when plans go wrong
A careful sitter has answers ready for these. Vague answers here are a reason to keep looking.
- What if you are running late or get sick? PSI says an emergency backup plan is a must for pet-sitting businesses and that clients should know what it is. Ask who covers and how you will be told.
- What happens in an emergency? Ask who they call first, how they would get your pet to your vet, and what written consent they need from you. The Danny's Pet Care Petsitting Form asks for your vet's details and your consent to take your pet to your vet in an emergency.
- Can you give my pet's medication? Ask how they give pills or liquids and how they record each dose. Danny's Pet Care gives medication as pills, liquid, or mixed into food. Any dose should match exactly what your vet prescribed.
- How will I hear from you? Ask whether updates come by text, photo or a note left at home, and how often. We send notes and photos after each visit.
- What if something looks wrong at the house? PSI tells sitters who find open or broken doors or windows not to go in, and to leave and notify the owner and the police. A sitter who already knows this is thinking about safety.
| Question | Why it matters | A careful answer usually includes |
|---|---|---|
| Who will visit, and who fills in? | You are handing over a key and your pet's routine. | Names, and how you will be told about a substitute. |
| What if you are sick or late? | Missed visits matter most on long workdays and trips. | A backup plan the sitter can describe clearly. |
| What do you do in an emergency? | A hurt or sick pet needs your vet quickly. | Calling you, getting to your vet, and your written consent. |
| How do you give medication? | Doses should follow your vet's directions exactly. | How they give it and how they record it. |
| How will I get updates? | Updates show the visit happened and flag changes early. | How and when you will hear after each visit. |
| How do you keep keys and codes? | Your home's security depends on it. | How keys are stored, labeled and returned. |
What a careful sitter asks you
A meet-and-greet runs both ways. PSI encourages sitters to walk through the home at the first meeting, both to learn where supplies are kept and to spot hazards such as broken locks or holes in a fence where a pet could get out. It also tells sitters to ask whether anyone else has access to the home.
Expect questions about your pet's health, temperament, routine and hiding spots, your vet, and how you want keys and alarm codes handled. Our Petsitting Form asks for your contact details, your pet's description, medical condition and favorite toys, your vet, special instructions, and consent for treats and emergency vet care.
You do not have to cover every detail out loud. For the written notes you leave behind, use our pet sitter instructions checklist. Keys, lockboxes and building access have their own guide on home access for sitters.
Running the meeting for a nervous dog or a shy cat
If your dog is wary of visitors, tell the sitter before they arrive. A guest article on the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB) website suggests having the visitor text on arrival instead of knocking, ignoring the dog at first (no looking, reaching or talking to her), and tossing small treats rather than using them to lure the dog closer. For a dog with a history of lunging or biting at visitors, the same article suggests keeping the dog on leash at a distance from the door or behind a gate.
Cornell University's College of Veterinary Medicine advises never forcing a fearful dog to interact with visitors, and letting the dog approach on its own. For cats, the AAFP and ISFM feline environment guidelines say people should not force interaction, should lower themselves to the cat's level, avoid fixed eye contact and give the cat time to approach.
A shy cat that stays under the bed for the whole meeting is not a failed meeting. What matters is that the sitter respects it and asks where the cat likes to hide.
Deciding after the meeting
Afterward, ask yourself whether the sitter answered plainly, listened, and treated your pet the way you would want. If you felt rushed, or the person could not explain how emergencies or sick days work, it is fine to say no. If your dog has a bite history or serious fear of people, talk with your vet about a qualified trainer or veterinary behaviorist before any sitter takes over.
If it feels right, the next step is paperwork and a first visit. New Danny's Pet Care clients find the Client Contract and Petsitting Form on our forms page, and you can contact us to book a meet-and-greet. Our dog sitting page describes how in-home care works, and the first-week checklist covers what to watch once visits begin.
When to call a vet
If your pet seems sick or hurt before or during the meet-and-greet, call your vet; the sitter search can wait. Make sure any sitter you hire has your vet's name and number, the nearest emergency animal hospital, and your written consent for emergency vet care. If you think your pet ate something toxic, call your vet or the ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center at (888) 426-4435; a consultation fee may apply.
Frequently asked questions
- How long should a pet sitter meet-and-greet take?
- There is no set length. It should be long enough for the sitter to meet your pet, walk through your home, see where supplies are kept, and go over your questions and their policies. For a nervous pet, a calm, unhurried meeting usually works better than a quick one. If your pet needs more time to warm up, ask whether a second short visit is possible before the first booking.
- Is a pet sitter meet-and-greet free?
- It depends on the company. Pet Sitters International says some companies offer the initial consultation at no charge and others charge a fee, so ask when you book. At Danny's Pet Care, every new client books a meet-and-greet through our application form before visits are scheduled, and our dog-sitting page describes it as a free consultation.
- Should my dog meet the dog walker before the first walk?
- In most cases, yes. A first meeting lets the walker see how your dog greets people, how your gear fits and how your dog leaves the house, and it lets your dog meet the walker with you there. Danny's Pet Care requires a meet-and-greet before visits begin. For a fearful dog, ask the walker to keep the first meeting low-key and to let your dog approach on its own.
- What should I tell a pet sitter about my cat?
- Tell them where your cat hides, how it acts with strangers, what and when it eats, how the litter box is set up, and anything your vet has said to watch for. The AAFP and ISFM feline guidelines say people should let a cat choose and control contact, so a sitter should not pull a shy cat out of hiding to say hello. Write the details down using our instructions checklist.
- What are red flags at a pet sitter interview?
- Be cautious if the sitter cannot say who will actually visit, has no backup plan for sick days, gives vague answers about emergencies or your vet, will not show proof of insurance or describe their background check, or ignores your pet's signals by reaching for a dog or cat that is clearly uneasy. Pressure to book on the spot is another reason to slow down and keep looking.
Next: talk it through with us
When you are ready, call 202-905-4684 or send us a message. Every new client starts with a meet-and-greet booked through our client forms.
Sources
- Pet Sitters International: Questions You Should Ask Any Potential Pet Sitter or Dog Walker
- Pet Sitters International: 4 precautions to take when arriving for a pet-sitting visit
- Pet Sitters International: Creating an Emergency Backup Plan
- AVSAB: Scaredy Dogs and Strangers, Part 1
- Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine: Fearful dogs
- AAFP and ISFM Feline Environmental Needs Guidelines
- ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center
- Danny's Pet Care: Dog Sitting Service
- Danny's Pet Care: Pet Sitter Service
- Danny's Pet Care: Services
- Danny's Pet Care: Pet Sitting in Washington DC FAQs
- Danny's Pet Care: Testimonials
Reviewed by Daniel R. Durand, Founder and CEO of Danny's Pet Care, on November 8, 2026. Written by Danny's Pet Care. Facts checked against the sources above on November 8, 2026. This guide is general information for pet owners in Northeast Washington, DC and Mount Rainier, MD. It is not veterinary or legal advice. Rules and health guidance change, so check with your vet, DC Health or Prince George's County before you act, and call your vet in an emergency.


